Music Plays (Dust by Tyler Fruik)
Gabe Nyen: Hey, welcome back to Asking the Experts, a podcast where we speak with natural resource scientists and managers about where their work intersects with climate adaptation and applied ecosystem management. If you’re tuning back in, welcome to another episode of Season 2. I’m your host, Gabe Nyen. Today, we’re speaking with Dr. Morgan Varner, and here’s that episode.
Today, we’re speaking with Dr. Morgan Varner. And Morgan, thank you very much for joining the podcast today. I’m super appreciative. So, can you please take a minute and describe what you do right now and then describe your overarching career for me? What does that look like, and what brought you to this moment in time?
Dr. Morgan Varner: Okay. Well, I’m the Director of Research and a senior scientist at Tall Timbers. Tall Timbers is a research station and land conservancy based in Tallahassee, founded in the late 1950s. Place-based research organization focused on prescribed fire, specifically the biology and management of bobwhite quail and the biodiversity consequences of the use of fire for quail management.
I’ve been here for about seven years. Before that, I was a scientist with Forest Service Research and Development based in Seattle at the Pacific Wildland Fire Sciences Laboratory. Before that, a professor for 12 years, most recently Virginia Tech in the forestry program, Mississippi State in the forestry program, and Humboldt State for eight of those 12 years in the forestry program.
At Tall Timbers, I administer—I’m one of those—overall of our research programs. We have seven research labs that are focused on those three big topics: fire, quail, and biodiversity. And I manage to keep my own research program going where I can continue a couple branches of my research efforts that I started 25 or 30 years ago, focusing on fundamentally how trees and plants survive in fire-prone environments. And so I do that from a classical way of looking at post-fire tree mortality and that sort of discipline. And somewhat unique to that field, I also overlay that with the traits of species to try to understand not just the pattern across species, but to try to get at the underlying mechanisms and how that relates to, you know, why a species is here and not there, why it survived or didn’t, why it’s growing well or is suffering.
Gabe Nyen: All right. That’s really cool. Tree — [laughter] Tree mortality and fire are being spoken about a lot these days. Has it been equally as spoken about during the course of your career? Have you seen that develop and change over time?
Dr. Morgan Varner: Yeah, it’s interesting. A lot of fire ecology and I guess forest ecology as well are provincial, they’re place-based. You know, there are a lot of local stories and local interest in local species that are in your area. My PhD work was focused on post-fire mortality of long-unburned sites. Places that typically burn every other year and that at that time, and still today, hadn’t had fire in decades, you know, four or five decades.
Gabe Nyen: We’re talking about prescribed fire?
Dr. Morgan Varner: Talking about prescribed fire, yeah. And that PhD work really started in my undergraduate, where I was working on a project where they were trying to reintroduce fire to a long-unburned site, and it was much more difficult to put fire back into a site than it was to burn a site on a regular interval. And I saw the problems at that time, and everyone else saw it. And so there was quite a bit of interest in the region over that phenomenon. And then once I really delved into it, my PhD, I moved to California, and there were a whole host of other issues with post-fire tree mortality that were radically different. And I think that’s been the case wherever I’ve worked. You know, in the Southeast, I work on the most fire-tolerant species maybe in the world, and so thinking about what causes a tree to die is much more a freakish phenomenon. You know, why in the world did that one tree on an acre die is a very different question than the entire stand is dead or a pattern that we can all see. It tends to be much more stochastic and, you know, oddball sorts of situations. But this last year with heavy drought and a lot of beetle activity, Ips activity in particular, people were more interested in my topic that I always feel like, “Oh, don’t ask the guy who knows… That guy’s just going to say something about, you know, fire and tree death.” But this year was a different year.
Gabe Nyen: Yeah. It sounds like you’ve really spanned a lot of ecosystems and places within your scientific career. Can you tell me about what the most exciting part of this career has been?
Dr. Morgan Varner: Yeah, that’s a good question. Is it ecosystem-based? Is it place-based? Is it research time? I don’t know. I feel like from a research standpoint, the most exciting part has been sort of delving into the evolutionary relationships of fire and species. That part I think is the funnest, just because it’s kind of like an ecological story that you heard in a lecture when you were an undergrad and got you really excited. And that part has been fun because you’re making discoveries of stuff that we should have discovered 200 years ago. [laughter] So that’s a little ridiculous. And so when you do it, you’re like, “Oh my gosh, I can’t believe we finally figured out this thing we should have known.” But I’d say the most like professionally rewarding stuff has been sort of policy and implementation stuff. In California, I was surprised when I got there that in all these fire-prone ecosystems, prescribed fire was almost not even mentioned. And, you know, I thought I was missing something for the first year, so I’d say something about prescribed fire and people would look at me in a strange way. And then later on, I just got to where I decided that I would be the burr under the saddle and say, “Well, if we used prescribed fire here, none of this would have happened,” and been that sort of person. And it really helped inspire people to make change. And I think that part—you know, you can do science and write a cool paper and get cited and have like whatever that shot of adrenaline or ego in it is, but when you go out to a landscape and people are doing something very different, it means a lot. I think that extends from sort of inspiring managers and scientist-activists to some of the policy work. I do an increasing amount of work in Washington, D.C. in the halls of Congress and knowing that your expertise in a topic could change not just a county in North Mississippi, but it could change how stuff is done across large landscapes. That’s super cool. And if you feel passionately about it and you have the expertise in something, I think it’s sort of what a lot of us want. We want our work to matter. And it’s one of those places where the everyday person is not going to care whether I figure out that branch bark thickness differs among the Southern pines, [laughter] but they are going to care if they’re not inundated by smoke as much, or their lives aren’t interrupted by wildfire, or their jobs aren’t imperiled, or they lose their house. And I think those are the kind of things we all want. We want our science to be meaningful.
Gabe Nyen: Right. Those are really big questions that I find myself answering or asking myself really frequently. What’s the tradeoff between the smoke from a prescribed fire over a roadway causing a slowdown versus the huge change in someone’s life from a wildfire encroaching their home, let alone taking their house, or a neighborhood or a city? Those are really big questions. So, with those big questions in mind, what kind of large intellectual questions do you find yourself mulling over these days?
Dr. Morgan Varner: Well, the thing that—you know, I was trained as a forester and trained as an ecologist, specifically focused on fire. The thing that has really dominated my waking time over the last three or four years has been smoke from prescribed fire. Yeah. It used to be when people would talk about—I used to teach the topic, and teaching fire behavior for 15 years, thinking about smoke was sort of like, “Yeah, we got to talk about smoke, and guess what, it’s bad for people, and also it could go on a highway and cause traffic fatalities,” which is very different than how in the world do we live with this much fire and not really living with the fire, but living with the smoke? And to me, that is the future of prescribed fire. And the future of prescribed fire is the future of biodiversity, it’s the future of how these ecosystems function. We can do all these other things to structure them, to have the right composition, but if fire is absent, it’s hard to imagine how any of these species make it, whether they’re plant or animal. We’d build museum pieces where we would be mowing and doing all these things that seem antithetical to biodiversity and would have a very different long-term consequence for structure and composition. And so the real hinge on fire’s future is not—to me, it’s not as much liability, like if you burn down someone’s house and that is going to fundamentally change how prescribed fire is, I’ve just seen enough of it to know that those are unfortunate blips. But the real problem is chronic public health issues. And until the broader natural resource community and specifically the prescribed fire community acknowledges that and embraces it, we’re going to be in trouble. It’s sort of this—we know there’s a ticking time bomb there. And so it’s been something that’s been in my mind because there were some EPA regulations that changed. People may not have ever heard of it, but for us in the prescribed fire world, it was this massive moment, and it made us say, “Damn it, we should have taken care of this a long time ago. We should have figured out how we burn near communities, not to scare them about flames or interrupt their lives, but how do we manage smoke better so that we can coexist?” And that to me I think is our future challenge. Even though I have no training in it, even though I have no expertise in it, [laughter] it’s something that I’ve thought about all the time, and I’m trying to do as many things as I can to help support those sorts of programs and to lean in on it and not sort of say there’s nothing to see here, which is a very frequent thing. We do it in forestry and we do it in fire. You know, “Smoke? Oh, it’s not that bad.” We know that’s not the case. And so I think leaning into it and figuring out ways we get over it in the future from a policy standpoint, but really from an implementation standpoint is—that’s really what dominates my thinking.
Gabe Nyen: Yeah. And what directionality are you taking from there? Where are you trying to make changes that you’re capable of? What do you think that you have a grasp of?
Dr. Morgan Varner: Yeah. Well, I think it’s sort of multi-part. There is clearly a Washington, D.C. approach, engaging with the EPA and other agencies, engaging with the cognizant committees in the House and the Senate and the people that matter in those. But it’s also on the ground. You know, we’ve tried to, in Southwest Georgia, pull together prescribed burn practitioners and the state agencies, both air quality and prescribed fire permit authorizers or regulators, pull everyone together as much as we can, working with diverse partners, but really with the boots on the ground saying, “If we don’t change our ways, we won’t be able to do this in the future.” And right now, we founded a smoke science program at Tall Timbers two and a half years ago just to do this, so we’d have an expert and not someone like me, a charlatan. [laughter] Okay. And what we’re trying to do now is to do that both locally in the Red Hills of South Georgia and North Florida around the Tallahassee area, but also to do it in the West—in California, Washington, Colorado, and Montana. We’re now starting to get to where we can propose those, help those sorts of communities do the same thing. Their problem is different than ours. For us, we’re trying to maintain—and increase, but maintain is the real challenge here. We don’t kid ourselves. We’re not trying to double the prescribed fire in the Tallahassee-Thomasville area in the next five years. That’s not a realistic goal. We’re trying to maintain as much as we can and have perhaps incremental increase. In the West, they’re talking about 10-fold, 20-fold increases in prescribed fire. And so if they’re having issues now with really background levels of prescribed fire smoke, very low levels, imagining it where there’s 10 times as much burning, and it’s all concentrated during the appropriate windows, let alone they also have wildfire smoke they’re still dealing with, right, that’s a really big challenge. And so we’re trying to take what we’ve learned here—not that we take an Albany, Georgia model and export it, but we’re trying to take what we learn from that and help other communities get ahead of the game, or at least catch up, because I think in 10 years, I think we’ll be having these existential moments for prescribed fire, and it’ll be related to smoke, not from a house burned down or a garage burned down or something, it’ll be a public health burden.
Gabe Nyen: Yeah. Over my years living across the country, I think that I’ve experienced a lot of different types or flavors of smoke, different thicknesses, different intensities. Some of the worst ones are concentrated in places where there’s not prescribed fire around. It’s residual smoke from wildfires. It’s intense. Living in the Twin Cities and having wildfire smoke, or I lived in Billings, Montana, and worked on the top floor of a tall building and was able to see just smoke sit across the entire landscape on this day. That was really intense. And here in the Southeast, the fire smoke doesn’t hurt as bad, if not, it almost is inviting to walk out into the air and smell it and taste it in the morning. It’s a totally different thing. So, I think about climate change, and I think about forestry and silviculture and Southern pines and how these different things are going to move forward through climate change in different ways. How does your work interact with climate change with smoke and prescribed fire and these things, and where’s that intersection at with forestry?
Dr. Morgan Varner: Yeah, that’s an interesting question. We get it a lot for fire because when you have an anomalous year, which is almost every year, [laughter] counter to the definition of anomalous, people, you know, it’s convenient to say how is climate change—you know, how can we implicate climate change in this? And as a scientist, my role is to be cautious and to say, “Well, wait a minute, there are other more plausible—you know, this could be the outcome, this might be the driver, or here’s how it would work.” From a general prescribed fire standpoint, a prescribed fire is ignited on a day. It’s a weather phenomenon. Weather matters for prescribed fire more than climate does. A year could be parched, bone dry, it could be record dry in the summer, and it’s three or four months after we’ve ended our prescribed fire season. So it doesn’t matter what happens in August if we’re burning in March. And so a lot of prescribed fire tends to be the moment, and the sort of accumulated climate change impacts can be muted. That said, [laughter] we’re starting to see lots of things that even—you know, I’m not a climate change denier, but as a scientist, I try to deny as much as possible and wait until my null hypothesis is laughed out of the building. And, you know, there are a lot of situations. In the West, I think we see fire seasons so much earlier than we did even 20 years ago. The record from the last 50 years, you know, when in the late ’70s and mid-1980s in California, people were like, “What in the world is going on with these wildfires?” They were happening August, September, October. And, you know, now those are June fires in areas where there still should be snowpack that’s retreating. It’s basically our spring weather. And that, I think we see some pretty clear signals. From a prescribed fire standpoint, because we have a window that is weather, that the accumulated window—the individual number of days that are open to us—are really climate. There’s been a lot of hand waving, some scratching the surface research that shows that the window’s going to be more difficult in the future. Some of that is like, whatever. But we’re seeing the vegetation respond differently, and so our weather windows are not arbitrary. They’re being burned at a certain time because, for us, specifically in the Red Hills, most of the burning is for bobwhite quail. Burning really takes off at the end of quail hunting season prior to nesting season. And so you take the entire year and you combine it into 8 to 12 weeks at the most. Really, 8 weeks is about what you have. And if a March of 2026 is different than a March of 1976, then—and I mean that from a quail behavior standpoint, it may be that they start to call earlier, it may mean that they’re mating earlier, it may mean nesting earlier. All these things start to happen earlier, or it might be that the vegetation fundamentally is leafing out earlier, doing— it’s going through physiological processes that a fire in 1976, when all of our research was focused on control of these species, they were all still asleep. They were all dormant, and we were hitting them when they were down or they just started to leaf out. And now we’re hitting them where they’ve already started to have positive carbon. They’re already storing carbon. And so hitting them now may be just fine. And I think we’re gonna start to see some of that stuff play out over the coming decades. But from a prescribed fire standpoint in the Southeast, we’ve seen very little. Even though, you know, this year was record-breaking in all senses of that phrase, you know, burning still happened.
Gabe Nyen: Yep.
Dr. Morgan Varner: There is some elevated mortality of southern pines, and it’s a complicated story, as it always is with mortality. Mortality is never silver bullet. We know this is the thing that caused it. What we see, tend to see, is a multitude of factors. And this year, having it really, really dry certainly didn’t help.
Gabe Nyen: All right. I’ve had a really enjoyable time hearing about all these different nuances to fire and burning and the ecosystems. And it sounds like you take a lot of your work from an ecological lens, which is really neat. And I think that, I think a lot of modern forestry is starting to look through that ecological lens more and more.
Dr. Morgan Varner: Mm-hmm.
Gabe Nyen: I’ve got a new podcast, and I’m wondering what your thoughts are on how a podcast or how a new vessel for delivering forestry information, scientific information to a crowd that’s interested, what might that look like and what might a positive way to frame that be?
Dr. Morgan Varner: Well, I mean, we’ve undergone in education, and I would put some air quotes around that, tremendous change over the last decade. You know, I stopped being a professor in 2016, and 2016 was before COVID. 2016, you know, what a radically different time, right? I was a professor from 2004 to 2016, how different things were. You know, when I would do things in 2004, the professors that were from the ’70s and ’80s that were ending their career would go, “What kind of ridiculous is—I can’t believe you’re doing that.” And you tend to have innovation in those settings, which is what universities have always been, these hubs of innovation. And so in how we reach people, because everyone is not you, everyone is not—there’s not a median student that you can get to.
Gabe Nyen: Right.
Dr. Morgan Varner: And what you’re trying to do in those situations is get to them. Podcasts are interesting because you do have to be interested to get to it. There’s a barrier to entry that is you have to be interested. So I like that. I like the multiple sources just because in my classroom I used a whiteboard with a marker or a chalkboard with a piece of chalk because I noticed that folks would get glazed over when there was a PowerPoint, the sort of death by PowerPoint kind of phenomenon.
Gabe Nyen: Totally. Definitely.
Dr. Morgan Varner: And I felt like sometimes they were in their heads criticizing a color or the fonts didn’t look quite right. So they had turned into sort of passive observers instead of active participants, which is what I loved about chalk and a whiteboard marker is that they were having to write the graph. And if you can’t draw a graph with the relationship if you don’t understand it. So you have to immediately raise your hand, whereas you could sit back and see the graph and say, I already have the notes printed out for me. So I like there being different ways to reach them. If everybody else in my department had used chalk and a whiteboard, I probably would have used only PowerPoint, you know, something just that was different.
Gabe Nyen: Okay.
Dr. Morgan Varner: So that the students would not feel like they’re passive. I always wanted them to be active participants. When you’re selecting something to listen to or to watch or something else, you’ve already played an active role in it. And as you’re letting it go and you’re stopping it, rewinding, doing that sort of thing, as you’re interacting with it, it is learning. And I like that. I feel like what really the whole world since COVID from an educational standpoint and delivery, is a real—we went to such a passive period there where you were little boxes on a screen while your professor was at their house and you were in your dorm room or your house, to, you know, we’re back trying to figure out how we do something hybrid or something else, but it’s really fundamentally changed how we learn. And I think technology is—it’s sort of stripping us down and saying, why couldn’t we do that?
Gabe Nyen: Yeah.
Dr. Morgan Varner: Why not do this? Why, you know, does it have to be a reading from pages 17 to 34 prior to the lecture tomorrow, or might it be listen to this podcast that’s 3 minutes and tomorrow I want you to present and I’ll sit back and, you know, like flipping a classroom or something like that? I think when you open it up to all possibilities, it’s where you get cool discovery, and I think you also are going to reach learners that you otherwise wouldn’t have reached.
Gabe Nyen: Okay. Well, those are really good thoughts, and I’ve got a million follow-up questions, but the first one coming to mind is how, like, we’re talking about learning and active learning and changing learning behaviors. Within your specialties, within the field, how do you see everyday citizens taking an active engagement approach into forestry and prescribed fire and smoke and fire on the landscape?
Dr. Morgan Varner: Mm-hmm.
Gabe Nyen: What’s that active role look like?
Dr. Morgan Varner: Yeah, I see it with fire a lot. I mean, there is sort of—we’ve done a lot, and I mean, when I say we, I mean for decades have done this where we’ll do sort of community learn and burn or something like that events. And it makes fire tactile. It makes fire where you can see it, observe it. And I think no human, whether it is coded very far back in our history, or just your observational skills now, could not be fascinated by fire’s movement, the way flames tilt, the way smoke moves, the human behavior around it, etc. Why in the world is there a bird now flying close to this plume? You know, that sort of stuff. That’s just all fascinating. So I think there’s that part. From a smoke standpoint, people are monitoring smoke in their own damn backyards.
Gabe Nyen: Yeah.
Dr. Morgan Varner: You know, and I think that to me is, they’re very interested in it. They’re interested in it from the public health standpoint. They wanna be protected.
Gabe Nyen: Right.
Dr. Morgan Varner: But I think there are then, it causes a necessary, now they’re going to where in the world are the permitted burns today? Why is there an 867-acre burn here and this one’s only 2 acres? What in the world’s a pile burn versus a whatever? And I think there’s also the accessibility of, you know, sort of the iNaturalist, eBird type stuff that it’s hard. It’s—this weekend I had a friend come in town who’s an ecologist, but he tends to work from space, not from the planet. And but he’s a, he’s a rabid birder, so much so that he’s one of those competitive birders.
Gabe Nyen: Oh.
Dr. Morgan Varner: And so, you know, I know my birds, okay? And so we were going out, but it got really, really fun by the end of the day. We were driving and it was sort of like, you know, slamming it in park and running out the window or running out the door with binoculars in hand and, you know, sort of falling down to be able to see and then arguing over what the bird was. It was this competitive birding that he was doing with another friend. And, uh, but it was like you couldn’t escape, even though I’m a fire ecologist, you couldn’t escape that the damn site just burned. You know, it has to overlay that land management has occurred there. Something has happened there that is making that site really great for birds or, you know, or plants or whatever it is that they’re looking at. Uploading and interacting with. And I can see that sort of thing in the future much more, that the accessibility and the—for to be able to find the technology, to find the output, find the patterns, but also they’re inexpensive. You can do it yourself. And I think your connection to the ecological phenomena that everyone’s—I mean, I get excited about seeing flames.
Gabe Nyen: Yeah.
Dr. Morgan Varner: No one is not excited about seeing a roseate spoonbill fly over or swallowtail kite. And so I think, you know, that part, I—it’s hard for me right now to imagine how that is in the future. But I don’t think people are retreating into their, into their houses and, you know, beneath their sheets to scroll for, you know, 20 hours a day. I think it’s just going to make it where they’re engaged in a different way.
Gabe Nyen: Yeah, that’s really wonderful to hear. And I feel like I just learned a lot about you as a birder.
Dr. Morgan Varner: Competitive birder? Yeah, I’m not a competitive birder, but it was really fun.
Gabe Nyen: I feel like there’s a flavor of ecological scientist that is also really into birding.
Dr. Morgan Varner: Oh yeah.
Gabe Nyen: And then there’s the matrix of everyone that’s kind of into birding or also recognizes and has these birds in their back pocket and doesn’t just say, oh look, it’s a red one! And it’s a, it’s a whole spectrum, but I feel like a lot of ecologists kind of shift towards that. Well, I can memorize Latin names. Yeah, well, I can also memorize bird Latin names.
Dr. Morgan Varner: Yeah. Oh, we had—he had a couple of life birds that I was appalled that he did not, you know, did not already have.
Gabe Nyen: Okay.
Dr. Morgan Varner: Which became like part of the pursuit. You know, it was like, I’m getting you on that bird. I’m going to show you that bird if it’s the last thing I get through today.
Gabe Nyen: So did you tackle any?
Dr. Morgan Varner: Yeah, we did.
Gabe Nyen: Yeah. Which ones?
Dr. Morgan Varner: Yeah. Summer tanager. I was like outraged that he hadn’t seen a summer tanager. It’s so stunning. And they were calling through our yard, but he didn’t—he couldn’t put up—put his binoculars on it. And so, okay, that one’s fun. And then I’m ashamed to say it, a brown thrasher.
Gabe Nyen: Really?
Dr. Morgan Varner: And I was like, you’ve got to be kidding me. And it was flashing in front of us, you know, the entire day. And I was like, you didn’t see that one? No, I was paying attention to something else. And I was like, oh my gosh. Which was great.
Gabe Nyen: Cool. Cool. Well, for bird listeners, that’s Tallahassee suburbs, everyone.
Dr. Morgan Varner: There you go.
Gabe Nyen: Cool. Well, I’ve got maybe one, maybe two more questions. Is Dr. Death a name that’s thrown around in regards to you as a scientist? I feel like I heard that dropped in a side conversation standing near you at a conference once.
Dr. Morgan Varner: Yeah, I mean—.
Gabe Nyen: And I just want—I want the story behind this.
Dr. Morgan Varner: Well, there are a few Dr. Deaths, which is hilarious. One of my mentors from a, you know, not on my graduate committee, but certainly a leader in my field who I really looked up to when I was first learning how to do tree mortality was a scientist who was based in Seattle and then Missoula, Kevin Ryan. And that’s what they called—he was an early pioneer in a lot of the tree mortality work. He did great physiology as well as observational stuff in the field. And they called him Dr. Death. And the first time I ever chaired a special session, I had him come as kind of to close out this incredible session. And I introduced him as Dr. Death because that’s how I was introduced to him before.
Gabe Nyen: Okay.
Dr. Morgan Varner: And he looked at me and had this like offended look on his face, like, I can’t believe you said that. And I thought it was like such a cool thing. And then recently when I get introduced at things, people will say, you know, we have our own Morgan Varner, who’s also known as Dr. Death. And I’ll look at them in the same sort of way, like, I can’t believe you’re saying that. And it is—it’s sort of like, there’s a—if you work on post-fire tree mortality, and you show up to a place, people look and go, what is Morgan? Oh, no. Like, they’re dead. He thinks there are dead trees here. So I’m never welcomed. They never go, please, we’d love to have you. They know why I’m there. And so I think that’s how that Dr. Death comes. I think there are at least 2 of us who are walking around who are Dr. Deaths right now. And my guess is that continues. And it, you know, kind of gets at the small size of our field, which, you know, always surprises me in whatever field you’re in.
Gabe Nyen: Yeah.
Dr. Morgan Varner: Just how few people there are that really are really delving into a topic that you think is the most important thing in the world. And then, you know, maybe it’s also an indicator of the gray hair that I have and my, you know, my age is that now I could be referred to as Dr. Death. When I was younger, I only went by my first name.
Gabe Nyen: Okay.
Dr. Morgan Varner: And then as I moved through my career, I became Dr. Varner.
Gabe Nyen: Yeah.
Dr. Morgan Varner: And now it’s just Dr. Death. So anyway.
Gabe Nyen: Yeah, it sounds like that mentor passed the drip torch on that name.
Dr. Morgan Varner: Yeah, absolutely.
Gabe Nyen: I like that.
Dr. Morgan Varner: Yeah. Okay, is there anything else that you want to share with anyone curious about fire, about smoke, about climate change, silviculture, forestry on the landscape, and all those interactions before we—yeah, I mean, I think the, you know, when you said you were coming down and we were going to go in the woods, you know, something I work with a lot of silviculturists, I’m not trained as one.
Gabe Nyen: Yeah.
Dr. Morgan Varner: But I work with a lot of silviculturists, both in my research and in teaching. And from a fire standpoint, I always, you know, 20 years ago, when I would talk about fire with silviculturists, they would go, oh my God, what a ham-fisted approach to, you know, manipulation of forest stands, that you would do it with fire, like it’s erratic, you know, it’s not a precise, not a surgical instrument. And, you know, thinking about it as a tool for silvicultural manipulation is one way to think about it. And I think sometimes silviculturists will put up a wall and say, I’m not considering fire in this. But the other way to think about it, and I think the way that people are really starting to appreciate it, is making silvicultural manipulations on landscapes and not thinking about what fire may do to them next week, a year from now, or 20 years from now. A lot of the manipulations we make on the landscape are to fire harden something, to make this site where it can tolerate—.
Gabe Nyen: Yeah.
Dr. Morgan Varner: A wildfire coming at, you know, this many chains per hour with this sort of intensity. And that’s great if the fire occurs at the point where everything has recovered to that and the trees have grown up to that phase. And I think what I see all the time and what I try to get across to silviculturists is in these situations, their pants are down right after the manipulation happens. There’s, there are all these other critical points, and how do they mitigate for that as they’re thinking in the future? That’s a classic silvicultural thing. What I love about silviculturists is they play the movie forward. They’re capable of not just working in space, but also working in time. And from a fire standpoint, I think it’s critical that they think about not how the perfect fire would occur here, but what’s the fire that takes all of your work and crumples it up and throws it in the trash can? And, you know, to me, that is when I see those sorts of treatments on the landscape, a silviculturist might look at it and say, what were they thinking? And I’ll look at it and say, that was a smart move. And I can’t believe they were thinking ahead because they knew that within the first 5 years they were going to be in real trouble. And so what they’ve done is they’ve done some bet hedging.
Gabe Nyen: Yep.
Dr. Morgan Varner: And this site is now capable of taking fire at any point. Um, it—you’ve—there’s a trade-off for growth, there’s a trade-off for something else in the interim, but this site is ready. And I think that is—there’s always this thinking man or woman’s forestry, which is how I’ve always thought about silviculture, is that it’s calm. You can make a thoughtful decision about the future. You know that an intervention now will have long-term consequences. And being able to do that, not just from how a tree would grow in nature with a dry year, a wet year, beetles are here or not, but do it with something that is such a landscape-dominant force and is becoming more dominant across the landscape, and that is fire, to me is the real test. That’s the graduate-level course, not the undergraduate where you go, yep, give a tree more resources and it grows better. That’s easy stuff.
Gabe Nyen: Right.
Dr. Morgan Varner: But imagining how a stand can respond to fire when it least can take it, to me, that’s the challenge.
Gabe Nyen: That’s a really awesome point. Thank you very much for saying all that. The fire thing that I keep thinking about in other parts of the country is fire as a community member, as a thing that existed within the landscape. When it wasn’t excluded, it formed all these tiny little habitats, and it did so much management on its own as a disturbance on the landscape. And within the Southeast, I’ve heard of a—a famous manager, use fire as a management tool that makes decisions for you because the ecosystem naturally had fire going through it. And so having that fire do the thing that it’s naturally capable of doing is a tool of betterment in some areas. And I think that playing with fire across the American landscape is a net positive into the future.
Dr. Morgan Varner: Yeah. You know, humans have been doing that for—.
Gabe Nyen: Right.
Dr. Morgan Varner: Is it 10, 15, 20, 25, 30,000 years in our area, longer in other places in the world? And I think that same kind of phenomenon, you know, I love to think about it playing with fire because it means that a human is doing it. I hate when we, you know, say that fire is natural or not natural because lightning did or didn’t.
Gabe Nyen: Right.
Dr. Morgan Varner: Humans have been using fire for a long time, and the only way we are going to live with fire in the future is with humans doing it. Um, and I—so I love the idea of, you know, keeping humans in the story, which is also a nice bridge for silviculture.
Gabe Nyen: Yeah, well, let’s pass the drip torch on that one.
Dr. Morgan Varner: Yeah.
Gabe Nyen: I really appreciate your time today, Morgan. Thank you so very much.
Dr. Morgan Varner: Yeah, my pleasure.
Music Plays (Dust by Tyler Fruik)
Transcript was produced using people and software – some errors
are possible.
All music rights are reserved by the artist.
